Guest Author: Cate Montana – “A Fish in Water”

by Cate Montana

Special to the Mountain News

 I was at a good friend’s wedding recently.  It was post-nuptials and post-dinner and people were having a good time on the outdoor dance floor.  Taking a breather, I retreated to an aerial perch in a treehouse built in a huge oak tree in the yard, about twenty feet above the foot-stomping local country band.

Guests I didn’t know ebbed and flowed through the treehouse, commenting on the view and quickly leaving to get back to the celebration.  But one woman hung around to talk.

“So, what do you do?” she asked.

“I’m a writer.”

At that she perked up.  “What do you write about?”

“I just finished my second book called Missing Woman: My odyssey to find the feminine in a masculine world.  It’s about how Western women have lost track of feminine values and so completely adopted the masculine paradigm from our male-dominated culture we don’t even know it.”

She looked simultaneously impressed and mildly disturbed.  “Really?  What made you write about that?”

What made me write about that?  Just my whole life – most of which had been spent trying to prove I was as good as a guy, working in all sorts of male dominated fields like live TV sports production.  It was a hard, high-stress business with gut-busting hours shlepping 60 pound cameras up to news booths in filthy stadiums in the rain and snow, all-night editing sessions and endless humiliating exposure to the de rigueur T&A (tits and ass) shots the camera guys, directors and other editors loved to shoot, oogle and use as “color shots” to segue into commercial breaks.

The cheerleaders and female fans eagerly complied – bending over to show their bottoms and popping open their blouses to show cleavage, shoving their boobs together with their hands – happy to be noticed by the cameras.  Usually I was the sole woman on headset in the TV trucks, and the comments I heard were … well, you can imagine.

To survive I became tough and competitive – just one of the guys.  As a result I was highly successful.  But there was a price.  You have to shut down to be tough – you have to shut down sensitivity and feelings.  Shut down grace, receptivity and sweetness.  It’s hard on the body, hard on the emotions and eventually hard on relationships.  Did I care at the time?  Hell no.  I’d bought my culture’s value system and thought life was all about going balls-out to have stuff, make money and be somebody.

My new friend listened to the story as the band twanged away below and our plastic wine glasses slowly emptied.  I took a sip and smiled.  “I thought being a successful woman meant the same thing as being a success as a woman.  I was so programmed to adopt aggressive masculine values I didn’t know there was any other way to be.  I was a fish in the water, you know?  I didn’t have a clue the reason I was busting a gut trying to measure up was because subconsciously I thought I was a second class citizen – and that my culture had actually taught me from infancy that I was.”

Laughter and clapping followed the band’s last song in the set.  My companion, who was probably in her early fifties, asked me questions and argued.  Did I really think women were still discriminated against?  Wasn’t that over long ago?  Hadn’t we won equality and moved on?

I talked statistics – how in the 21st century women were still paid less than men for the same jobs in the US.  How promotions come slower, if at all.  How the US was the only modern country in the world that had refused to legally mandate sexual equality.  How globally women comprise 50% of the world’s population, perform two-thirds of the labor, receive 10% of the world’s income and own less than 1% of global resources.  I talked about Muslim women routinely being operated on surgically without anesthesia, sexual mutilation of girls in Africa, girls sold into prostitution in first-world countries, female infants thrown out on dung heaps in China.

And I talked about the rape of the world – our Great Mother held hostage to corporate interests … and how, in our cultural obsession with money, profit and getting ahead, both men and women were now letting greed take precedence over life itself.

It was not your usual wedding conversation.

Visibly shaken, she asked me what I thought the solution was.  And I told her, “Women need to wake up to the fact that we’ve been programmed into a very different value system than is normal for us.  The feminine is about life – our values are life values: nurturing, love, family, community, connection, the well-being of all peoples, the well-being of the Earth, feelings and beauty and graciousness.

“We need to wake up and start operating from this place of life values inside us.  We need to value ourselves and recognize ourselves and love ourselves.  And we need to see the programs and thoughts we’ve bought into are polluted waters, no longer fit for anyone to swim in.”

She thanked me for sharing my perspective.  Thanked me for writing my book.  She said she hoped I got the word out to other women.  She said she hoped we all woke up in time.  Then she hugged me and climbed down the ladder to the party below.

©  2012  Cate Montana

Used with permission.

Editor’s Note: 

Cate Montana is a long-time journalist, having been the Northwest Bureau Chief for Indian Country Today for several years.  In addition, she has been a widely-read freelance writer, with her work appearing regularly in the Tacoma News Tribune.  Also, she has been the publisher of the Global Intelligencer, along with being the editor of The Bleeping Herald, the newsletter that accompanied the distribution of the transformative documentary, “What the Bleep Do We Know?!,” which explored the science of consciousness.

To learn more of Ms. Montana’s perspective on life, please visit her blog

Also, publication of her book on being a woman in a man’s world,  Missing Woman: My odyssey to find the feminine in a masculine world is expected in the near future.

Cate Montana

This entry was posted in Cate Montana, Culture, Folk tales and stories. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Guest Author: Cate Montana – “A Fish in Water”

  1. Wayne Cooke says:

    I’m somewhat familiar, through job and relatives, with a Native philosophy that encompasses respect for parents (including especially elders), respect for children, and respect for the environment that surrounds us and gives us life.
    Thank you for the provocative article! Is being a “man” being absorbed in who can beat who in sports, or the desire if not ability to use other people and resources (and others money) for one’s own gain? Is being a woman being able to love others and love the earth, itself, in the way Jesus tried to teach? Or is what you call being feminine being part of simply what all humans need to learn to be in order for all of us to survive. I’m aware that unkind decisions need to be made sometimes, and actions taken for long-term benefit but short-term pain.
    I wonder what your thoughts are when you think about it, not in terms of masculine/feminine, but in terms of caring behavior vs selfish behavior (such as corporations which are required by their charter to keep their shareholders happy). How do MEN such as Gandhi and King fit into this. They taught huge lessons. Cate, you may have to write another book!

  2. Cate Montana says:

    Hi Wayne – the more feminine qualities of connectivity, concern with mutual support, feeling, relating and compassion lie within all of us, both man and woman. Balance is the key, and our current cultural paradigm is radically skewed towards the more masculine qualities of intellectualism, “show me” materialism (none of that feel good “wu-wu” stuff), “power over the other guy” politics, competition and aggressive development at all costs: what I call the “P” values of power, possessions, profits and progress.

    You’re right, it’s not about masculine/feminine, but about values and the choices we make!

  3. Paula Morris says:

    Wow! This is a thought provoking article as well as a thought provoking comment by Wayne Cooke. I have to admit that I am of the “feminist” persuasion and have many of the same thoughts and issues as Cate Montana. Actually, I could write a book about my struggle to rebel against the patriarchy we live in….and am working on it.

    Wayne…I believe you are absolutely right if I consider honestly what you said. There are many men (yourself included) who are caring decent human beings. The issue here however is living in a masculine dominated world (or patriarchy) which almost demands “power-over” tactics in order to be considered a winner. Yes, men suffer from this mentality as well as women. It is called “The Masculine Protest” in Adlerian jargon (by which I have been trained as a therapist) and basically speaks to this issue that Cate Montana writes about…..women feeling like second class citizens and men who don’t follow the macho rules feeling like losers.

    The issue is a world view that refuses to allow the “feminine” perspective any honor or divinity. It’s much much worse than just caring vs selfish. A world view that de-values caring and softness rather than embracing them, sets up a paradigm whereby violence, rape, war, and power predominate. It causes an imbalance. If you visualize the ying/yang sign you see a white side with a black dot and a black side with a white dot. This is the symbol of all in balance and harmony….masculine/feminine, black/white, dark/light….these dichotomies are necessary and they need to balance each other.

    So, even if SOME men are sensitive,caring and self-less and even if SOME women are aggressive, greedy, power-mongers….the basic world paradigm in which we live worships the masculine perspective and denigrates the feminine perspective. We need to change this.

    My quest was to find the “Feminine Face of God” and I did. But then, this is a story all its own. I’ll save that for another time. I strongly identify with Cate Montana’s thesis of “finding the feminine in a masculine world.” If only we find this balance in time, we could change the consciousness of humanity and perhaps avoid the destruction of our planet.

    I was excited by this article. It is re-motivating me to re-kindle my enthusiasm for writing again.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s